William wants to get Andy back for beating him up in ANDY KICKS WILLIAM'S BUTT!!!. So he steals his beloved Christmas hat and locks him, along with Violette, outside the house. Andy, understandably angry, begs William to give him back his hat and let him back inside. William then leaves the house with lighter fluid, a lighter and Andy's hat and gets into the SUV and locks Violette and Andy out. Andy then climbs on the vehicle's roof and yells at William through the sunroof, asking him, once again, to give him back his hat. William then starts the car and drives away, as Violette flips out. Violette walks around in front of the house for a few minutes, hearing Andy continuously yelling "Give me my hat!" in the distance. William returns without Andy on the car's roof. As Andy comes running back, William sets Andy's hat on fire. Andy attempts to put the fire out by hitting the hat with his jacket, only to ruin his jacket in the process. William thinks it's hilarious but Violette feels bad for Andy. The video ends with William and Andy fighting.